What Are Bitcoin Improvement Proposals (BIP)?

Want to learn more about crypto?
Explore more on our blog!
Learn more
A colorful image of a bitcoin.
Table of Contents
A colorful image of a bitcoin.

Key Takeaways:

  • Bitcoin Improvement Proposals (BIPs) are formal proposals that allow the Bitcoin community to organize and make decisions
  • BIPs serve a vital purpose in the Bitcoin community by providing a structured framework for proposing and discussing changes to the Bitcoin protocol
  • Through open collaboration and democratic decision-making processes, BIPs help drive forward-thinking solutions

What are Bitcoin Improvement Proposals (BIP)?

Bitcoin Improvement Proposals (BIPs) are formal proposals that allow the Bitcoin community who runs nodes to organize and make decisions about improving the cryptocurrency’s protocol, enhancing its functionality, and driving innovation in the ecosystem.

This article will demystify BIPs, offering a simplified insight into their creation, purpose, and immense value they hold within the decentralized world of Bitcoin.

Are you ready for your guided tour into the backbone of Bitcoin’s innovation?.

Definition of BIPs

Bitcoin Improvement Proposals, widely known as BIPs, are formal documents that propose modifications and advancements to the Bitcoin protocol. Coined by Amir Taaki in 2011, the term refers to a design document providing information or proposing a new feature for Bitcoin or its processes.

These proposals contribute significantly to Bitcoin’s development roadmap, offering an organized platform for introducing potential improvements. With an objective of creating a clear understanding of proposed alterations among community members, they play a vital role in preserving and fostering consensus within the decentralized environment of this digital currency ecosystem.

Purpose of BIPs

Bitcoin Improvement Proposals (BIPs) serve a vital purpose in the Bitcoin community. They function as a structured framework for proposing and discussing changes to the Bitcoin protocol, ensuring that all relevant stakeholders have a say in the evolution of this digital currency.

BIPs allow developers, researchers, and users to collaborate and contribute their ideas to enhance the functionality and security of Bitcoin. By providing clear guidelines and documentation, BIPs streamline the decision-making process within the community, fostering consensus on proposed upgrades or improvements.

The purpose of BIPs is to facilitate innovation, advancement, and continuous development within the Bitcoin ecosystem while maintaining its decentralized nature.

Process of Creating BIPs

Creating a Bitcoin Improvement Proposal (BIP) involves the following steps:

  1. Idea Generation: Community members propose ideas for improving Bitcoin’s functionality, scalability, or security.
  2. Drafting the BIP: The proposer creates a draft document outlining the proposed changes or enhancements to Bitcoin. The BIP should include a clear problem statement, proposed solution, and technical specifications.
  3. Feedback and Discussion: The proposer shares the draft BIP with the Bitcoin community for feedback and discussion. This allows other community members to provide input, suggest modifications, and raise concerns.
  4. Revision and Refinement: Based on the feedback received, the proposer revises the BIP accordingly. They address any concerns raised by the community and ensure that the proposal aligns with Bitcoin’s principles.
  5. Seeking Co-Authors: In some cases, multiple individuals may collaborate on a BIP to enhance its credibility and gain broader support from the community. Co-authors are typically experts in their respective fields related to the proposal.
  6. Obtaining Consensus: Once the BIP has been revised and refined, it is important to seek consensus within the Bitcoin community. Consensus can be achieved through discussions on mailing lists, forums, or social media platforms like Reddit.
  7. Submitting the BIP: After achieving consensus, the final version of the BIP is submitted to one of several online repositories that host BIPs such as GitHub or Bitcoin.org.
  8. Review Process: The submitted BIP undergoes a review process where experts from various fields evaluate its technical feasibility, potential impact on network security and performance, alignment with existing standards, etc.
  9. Adoption or Rejection: Depending on its review results, a BIP may be adopted if it receives sufficient support from community members and core developers in charge of implementing protocol changes. If there are significant concerns or objections raised during reviews, a BIP may be rejected or sent back for further iterations.
  10. Implementation: If a BIP is approved, Bitcoin core developers may begin implementing the proposed changes into the Bitcoin protocol. This includes coding, testing, and deploying the updates on the Bitcoin network.
  11. Deployment and Activation: Once implemented, the proposed changes need to be deployed on the Bitcoin network. Activation typically occurs through a consensus mechanism such as miner signaling or user-driven upgrades.
  12. Monitoring and Evaluation: After deployment, ongoing monitoring and evaluation of the implemented changes ensure that they function as intended and do not introduce any unexpected issues or vulnerabilities.

Importance and Significance of BIPs in the Bitcoin Community

BIPs are important in the Bitcoin community, facilitating discussions, driving innovation, and ensuring consensus on network upgrades.

Facilitating Discussions and Decision-Making

Bitcoin Improvement Proposals (BIPs) facilitate discussions and decision-making processes. These proposals allow members of the community to communicate their ideas, suggestions, and concerns regarding the Bitcoin protocol and ecosystem.

Through BIPs, developers and enthusiasts can propose changes or improvements to be considered by the wider community.

The significance of BIPs lies in their ability to bring diverse perspectives together, leading to decisions that benefit the entire community. By submitting BIPs, individuals contribute to a collaborative environment where ideas are shared openly, fostering innovation and development within the Bitcoin ecosystem.

BIPs enable consensus-building among community members. Through extensive discussions facilitated by these proposals, stakeholders can weigh different perspectives before making important decisions on upgrades or modifications to the Bitcoin network.

Consensus is vital for maintaining trust and stability within decentralized systems like Bitcoin.

Driving Innovation and Development

Bitcoin Improvement Proposals (BIPs) drives innovation and development within the Bitcoin community. By allowing members to propose changes and improvements to the Bitcoin protocol, BIPs provide a platform for new ideas and advancements.

This fosters an environment of continuous evolution, ensuring that Bitcoin remains at the forefront of digital currency technology.

Through BIPs, community members can share their innovative concepts and suggestions for improving various aspects of Bitcoin functionality. This open collaboration encourages creativity and pushes the boundaries of what is possible with cryptocurrency.

As a result, new features are integrated into the Bitcoin protocol, enhancing its capabilities and expanding its potential applications.

BIPs serve as guidelines for developers seeking to contribute to the growth of the ecosystem. They offer clear documentation on proposed changes or enhancements, making it easier for developers to understand how they can contribute to driving innovation forward.

Ensuring Consensus and Network Upgrades

Bitcoin Improvement Proposals (BIPs) play a crucial role in ensuring consensus among the Bitcoin community and facilitating network upgrades. BIPs allow Bitcoin users to propose changes or enhancements to the protocol, which are then thoroughly discussed and debated within the community.

This collaborative process ensures that any proposed changes have broad support and agreement from stakeholders.

Consensus is essential for maintaining the decentralized nature of Bitcoin, as it ensures that all participants are on the same page regarding network upgrades. Through BIPs, developers can present their ideas for improving the functionality or security of Bitcoin, opening up discussions with other experts in the field.

This transparent dialogue helps identify potential issues and find solutions that benefit all users.

Not only do BIPs foster consensus within the community, but they also drive network upgrades. When a proposal gains sufficient support and technical scrutiny, it can lead to actual code implementation and deployment.

These upgrades can include improvements in transaction speed, scalability, privacy features, or even new functionalities like smart contracts.

Types of Bitcoin Improvement Proposals (BIPs)

Bitcoin Improvement Proposals (BIPs) come in various types, including Standards Track BIPs, Informational BIPs, and Consensus BIPs. To learn more about each type and their significance in the Bitcoin community, keep reading.

Standards Track BIPs

Standards Track BIPs are a type of Bitcoin Improvement Proposal that outline changes to the Bitcoin protocol and suggest new standards for implementation. These proposals lay down specific rules and guidelines, aiming to improve various aspects of the Bitcoin ecosystem.

Standards Track BIPs ensure that proposed modifications are thoroughly tested, well-documented, and aligned with the overall vision of Bitcoin development. Through these proposals, developers can propose upgrades or enhancements to address issues such as security vulnerabilities or network scalability concerns.

Informational BIPs

Informational BIPs provide educational resources and informative guidelines. These proposals are not focused on introducing changes to the Bitcoin protocol but rather aim to enhance understanding and provide valuable information to users, developers, and other stakeholders.

Informational BIPs cover a wide range of topics such as explaining complex technical conceptsoutlining best practices for security or privacy measures, or providing detailed documentation on specific aspects of the Bitcoin ecosystem.

By making this knowledge accessible and easily understandable, informational BIPs contribute to empowering individuals and promoting a more informed and educated community.

Consensus BIPs

Consensus BIPs propose changes to the consensus rules that govern how transactions are validated and added to the blockchain. These proposals aim to improve the security, efficiency, or functionality of the Bitcoin network.

Consensus BIPs require broad community consensus before they can be implemented, ensuring that any proposed changes receive thorough scrutiny and discussion from stakeholders. Notable examples of Consensus BIPs include BIP 141 (Segregated Witness), which increased block capacity and improved transaction malleability, and Taproot (BIP 340), a proposed upgrade focused on enhancing privacy and smart contracts capabilities within Bitcoin.

Notable Bitcoin Improvement Proposals (BIPs)

Some notable Bitcoin Improvement Proposals (BIPs) include BIP 21 with simplifying payments, BIP 141, or Segregated Witness, which introduced a new transaction format to improve scalability and eliminate certain vulnerabilities.

Another significant BIP is Taproot (BIP 340), which proposes an upgrade to Bitcoin’s scripting capabilities, enhancing privacy and enabling more complex smart contracts. BIP 9 (Versionbits) introduced a signaling mechanism for activating soft forks in the Bitcoin network.

These BIPs demonstrate the continuous innovation and development within the Bitcoin community.

BIP 141 (Segregated Witness)

BIP 141, also known as Segregated Witness, is one of the most notable Bitcoin Improvement Proposals that has had a significant impact on the Bitcoin community. Introduced in 2015, BIP 141 aimed to address the issue of transaction malleability and increase the block size limit without requiring a hard fork.

This proposal introduced a new way of storing signature information separately from transaction data, resulting in more efficient use of space within blocks.

The implementation of BIP 141 brought several benefits to the Bitcoin network. It increased transaction capacity by allowing more transactions to be included in each block. This helped alleviate congestion and reduce fees for users sending or receiving Bitcoin.

By separating signatures from transaction data, BIP 141 enhanced the security and privacy aspects of Bitcoin transactions.

With its successful activation in August 2017 after gaining widespread support from miners and developers, BIP 141 demonstrated the power of collaborative decision-making within the decentralized Bitcoin community.

It showcased how an improvement proposal could lead to advancements in functionality while maintaining consensus among stakeholders.

Taproot (BIP 340)

Taproot (BIP 340) is a proposed upgrade to the Bitcoin protocol that aims to improve privacy, scalability, and flexibility. It introduces a new smart contract mechanism called Schnorr signatures, which enable multiple parties to collaborate on creating complex transactions while only revealing minimal information on the blockchain.

This enhances privacy by making it difficult for observers to differentiate between regular transactions and more advanced smart contract transactions.

Besides privacy benefits, Taproot also promotes scalability by reducing transaction size, resulting in more efficient use of block space. This has the potential to lower fees and increase transaction throughput for the entire network.

Taproot improves flexibility by allowing developers to write sophisticated scripts with greater ease and efficiency. It simplifies the process of creating smart contracts while maintaining security and decentralization.

BIP 9 (Versionbits)

BIP 9, also known as Versionbits, is a significant Bitcoin Improvement Proposal that introduces a new signaling mechanism for activating soft forks in the Bitcoin protocol. This proposal provides a more efficient and decentralized process for determining which proposed changes to the protocol should be implemented.

Instead of relying on miner signaling alone, BIP 9 uses bit fields called “version bits” to allow all nodes in the network to express their support or opposition to specific upgrades or changes.

As a result, it ensures broader participation and consensus among community members before any modifications are made to the Bitcoin network. BIP 9 has played a key role in enhancing governance within the Bitcoin ecosystem by providing clear guidelines and improving decision-making processes when it comes to implementing protocol upgrades and improvements.


How Does the BIP Process Work?

The BIP process begins with a BIP submission, where individuals or teams propose a change to Bitcoin. The proposal goes through a review process by the Bitcoin community, including developers and other stakeholders.

Are There Different Types of BIPs?

Yes, there are different types of BIPs that address various aspects of the Bitcoin ecosystem. Some types include standards track BIPs, informational BIPs, and process BIPs.

Who Can Submit a BIP?

Anyone can submit a BIP, including Bitcoin developers, enthusiasts, or community members. BIPs can be proposed by individuals or groups of individuals.

Where Can I Find the BIPs?

The BIPs can be found in the Bitcoin Core GitHub repository. It serves as a central location for all BIPs and related discussions.

How Long Does It Take for a BIP to Be Accepted?

The time taken for a BIP to be accepted varies and depends on various factors. Some proposals can take years of discussions and refinement before being accepted.

Can Informal Proposals Be Considered as BIPs?

Informal proposals may be discussed within the Bitcoin community but are not considered official BIPs until they follow the proper submission process.

What is the Role of a BIP Champion?

A BIP champion is an individual who advocates for a specific BIP proposal and helps to drive its development and acceptance within the community.

Do All BIPs Require Universal Support?

Not all BIPs require universal support. Some BIPs may focus on specific aspects, functionalities, or improvements to Bitcoin and may not require unanimous agreement.

Can Proposals Be Submitted Outside of the Bitcoin Protocol?

Yes, proposals can be submitted that focus on improvements or changes outside of the Bitcoin protocol, such as interoperability with other cryptocurrencies or integration with external systems.

Conclusion: BIP Ensures the Blockchain Gets a Fair Consensus

BIPs are key in facilitating discussionsdriving innovation, and ensuring consensus for network upgrades.

By enabling collaboration and providing guidelines for evolution, BIPs contribute to the continuous improvement of Bitcoin’s functionality and advancement of its ecosystem. In a decentralized community where decision-making is distributed, BIPs serve as integral tools that empower individuals to shape the future of digital currency through their innovative ideas and proposals.



The information provided on this blog is for general informational and educational purposes only. It is not intended as financial, legal, or investment advice. Cryptocurrency investments are volatile and high risk in nature; it is possible to lose your entire investment. We are not financial advisors, nor do we purport to be.

While we strive to provide accurate and up-to-date information, we cannot guarantee the accuracy, completeness, or applicability of any information provided. The views and opinions expressed on this blog are solely those of the authors and should not be construed as professional advice. We do not endorse or guarantee the performance of any cryptocurrencies, projects, or companies mentioned herein.

Readers are encouraged to conduct their own research and consult with a professional financial and legal advisor before making any investment decisions. The owner of this website and the authors of its content will not be liable for any losses, injuries, or damages from the display or use of this information. Use of this information is at your own risk.

About the Author:
Alex Sterling stands at the forefront of blockchain innovation, offering a technical perspective rooted in a Computer Science background. Specializing in decentralized systems, Alex's articles dissect blockchain technologies and crypto market trends, making intricate details comprehensible for readers. They are deeply involved in blockchain project development, frequently sharing their technical expertise at tech conferences. Alex's work aims to educate and inspire readers about the transformative potential of blockchain and cryptocurrency.